After some investigation, I realized that the file it specified was only 25KB. However, at some point in its history it was over 100MB, Because I was pushing the entire commit history for that repository, it was rejecting everything.
The solution is to remove the file entirely from the repository’s history. It took some trial and error for me to find something that worked for me because most snippets relied on history already existing in the origin repository. Here is what worked for me:
git filter-branch --index-filter "git rm -rf --cached --ignore-unmatch path_to_file" HEAD
Hope this helps someone!